绿林网

Atonement读后感摘抄

Atonement读后感摘抄

《Atonement》是一本由Ian McEwan著作,Vintage出版的平装图书,本书定价:16.50美元,页数:384,特精心收集的读后感,希望对大家能有帮助。

《Atonement》读后感(一):后现代元小说的手法

终于看完。在情节上实在是not much happened,看到结尾感觉看到了后现代元小说的写法。以审稿编辑的口吻讨论前面的故事应该怎么写,Robbie和Cecelia到底活没活下来不重要了,重要的是读者想看一个happy ending,而作为小说家的Briony成全了他们,她与他们的浪漫通过这部小说能够活下去。标题叫《赎罪》,Briony去做护士去写这本小说就能赎罪了吗?显然不能。其实我也不知道这小说想表达什么。故事并不能让人读得酣畅淋漓,也许这就是后现代想要表达的效果——不要沉浸进去。并且在最后突然说:这都是假的呀!这是我的稿子!而作为小说之外的在读这本书的我们,这句statement依然是假的,虚构的。庄生梦蝶,何为真何为假,我们在看小说中人物的悲欢离合,谁又在看我们呢?

《Atonement》读后感(二):come back

Cecilia和Robbie送Briony坐地铁,Briony走进地铁站,就此永别姐姐和准姐夫。之后作者写下以下文字,终结小说惊心动魄的第三部分。

"... She was surprised at how serene she felt, and just a little sad. Was it disappointment? She had hardly expected to be forgiven. What she felt was more like homesickeness, though there was no source for it, no home. But she was sad to leave her sister. It was her sister she missed - or more precisely, it was her sister with Robbie. Their love. Neither Briony nor the war had destroyed it. This was what soothed her as she sank deeper under the city. How Cecilia had drawn him to her with her eyes. That tenderness in her voice when she called him back from his memories, from Dunkirk, or from the roads that led to it. She used to speak like that to her sometimes, when Cecilia was sixteen and she was a child of six and things went impossibly wrong. Or in the night, when Cecilia came to rescue her from a nightmare and take her into her own bed. Those were the words she used. 'Come back. It was only a bad dream. Briony, come back.' ..." (P. 349)

come back. 没有了爱和亲情,我们会是什么?面对亲手摧毁的爱和亲情,除了绝望,还能剩下什么?最后一刻,只有乡愁,永远剪不断。

《Atonement》读后感(三):Mistakes, consequences, and the whatifs

"Come back. I will wait for you."

It's a long journey. Deaths are around. Thirsty. Starved. Blistered. Tired. You keeps me walking. Every time touching your letter in the chest pocket. That moment, in the early morning mist, amid all the confusion and the judged hostility, you ran to me, your hand touching mine, cuffed in cold metal. It's a moment of ours that we claimed with right.

And you said:" It's ours. It's ours only. Come back. I will wait for you."

We were then worlds apart. Never to meet again.

Despite the title, the novel is not about atonement. It's not about Briony, though one cannot help feel sympathy for her own torturement, particularly in that tender moment in the ward when she fell in love with the French soldier, who died a moment later. Falling in futile love is one of her ways of atonement, in a way, I guess.

It's about how a random incident played its consequences in two people's lives. Powerful, irreversible, consequences. Love, despite the immense hopes that it carries, does not deliver the miracle that we are told to believe in. Cecilia and Robbie might as well marry someone else. Won't their lives be easier?

Yet, we love love. In the journeys we take, we think there is a goal that is loftier enough to rationalize all our doings in hindsight. Steve Jobs said so. One tried, crashed, burnt, redoubled, again, and again, until one finally found out that giving up is the best shortcut life has to offer.

It's in this light that I read "Atonement". I thought I am enlightened enough than this. But when Robbie joyously walked across the park to the dinner party, fully anticipating to marvel at the excitement of life that suppose to wait in his future, I realized with the gut wrenching I knew so well his doom was written long before Briony committed her "crime".

I wept for both Cecilia and Robbie, but mostly for Robbie. Though most of his peers suffered in their bodies, he suffered in his heart -- he is so driven to chase what he believes is his. And that rarely works.

Vivid, rich, in its every details. "Atonement" is an overwhelming experience for anyone who thinks he already knows enough, and yet, still quite cannot forget what he used to be.

《Atonement》读后感(四):Text Analysis of <Atonement>

本篇为英文文体风格鉴赏课程的期末文本分析作业。

Ian McEwan, a famous English novelist and screenwriter, who was born in a working class family in 1948. He first graduated from the University of Sussex, majoring in English literature, then received his master’s degree in literature form the University of East Anglia. He started his brilliant career as a writer in 1975 with a maiden work- a collection of short stories, named “First Love, Last Rites”. Gifted and diligent as he is, he rapidly gained fame with novels kept coming out, even got featured on the list of "The 50 greatest British writers since 1945" by The Times and ranked number 19 in their list of the "100 most powerful people in British culture" by The Daily Telegraph. These honors and awards have confirmed his position at the forefront of the contemporary British literary world, and have ensured him a niche in the British literary pantheon.

When reading his novels, you will be attracted to his prose if astonishing precision and power, and continually surprised by his ambition, breadth and tireless spirit for exploration of his scope.

In 2001, the novel Atonement came off the press, which falls under the genre of fiction, mystery and suspense, garnering acclaim promptly and widely regarded as one of Ian’s best and most influential works. Thus, it got its splendid film adaption in 2007 and was named in the list of “the 100 greatest English-language novels since 1923” by TIME magazine in 2010 undoubtedly. The book is set time of pre, present, and post World War II, just as McEwan’s habit as always anchoring his works in the past [1]. However, he is by no means a historical novelist for his novels attempting to reflect the Zeitgeist. Just as we can feel in Atonement, he portrayed how the ever-changing political, social, and cultural climate impacted the lives of ordinary or at times extraordinary people, like Robbie, Cecilia and Briony.

Atonement, as a massive hit in contemporary literature, is extraordinary in language, narrative techniques and theme, which tells a story of love, guilt, war, writing and imagination. The tragedy begins with Briony Tallis, the leading character and the narrator in this fiction, who mistakenly caused series of misfortune between her sister Cecilia and her beloved boyfriend Robbie, the son of their butler, finally leading them to separation and deaths. Suffering from the irretrievable mistake, Briony then spent her whole life writing the autobiographical novel Atonement, trying to atone for her own crime.

The novel consists of three parts and a postscript, with a time span of more than 60 years. Critics are always arguing whether placing it in the postmodernism of the turn of the century [2] or in the realism for it depicted the society and situation during World War II.

Part one is seemingly the closest the novel comes to modernism. It tells a story happened in a fateful hot summer day in 1935, when all the dramatic conflicts converge, in the abbey of the Tallis. Briony Tallis, the owner’s daughter, was at her age of thirteen, with rich immature imagination and a strong willing to write. Briony has her own system of representation of the world, with an acute sense of justice and order. However, she witnessed her sister Cecilia taking off her dress and jumped into the fountain in front of Robbie, which became the occasion of her first misguided interpretation of their relationship, read the wrong impolitic letter from Robbie to Cecilia, even discovered them intertwining in the study. A young girl at her age certainly thought he was a maniac and raped Cecilia. In the same night, when she ran into Lola, her cousin, being raped by a man Robbie’s height, she accused Robbie on no evidence to be the criminal without a haste. Robbie was sent to prison and forced to be apart from Cecilia sine then.

And here comes the second part took place in1940, with World War II going on. Robbie was sent to France to fight with the British Army in requital for being released from jail. The vivid and realistic relation of one day in Robbie’s war experience during the evacuation of Dunkerque (also Dunkirk in English), where, we will learn later, the injured Robbie lost his life for septicemia.

Part three is approximately contemporaneous with the previous part for it is based on the imagination and confession of Briony as no longer a “stupid child”. It is now focalized on Briony, who becomes a nurse in a London hospital, where Cecilia once worked, to expiate her crime against Robbie and her sister. She finally realized the inexcusable mistake was totally fabricated on her own thinking out of her ignorance, immaturity, impetuousness and even jealousy, so she screwed up her courage to talk these through Cecilia, while happen to meet Robbie at the same time. Things seem to get better.

The “London, 1999” in bold brings us back to reality all of a sudden. Readers are disappointed to find out that the happy ending was nothing but imagination or illusion, the truth is the couple never meet each other after departing and both died in 1940. The previous parts are all novels of Briony for the sake of memory and atonement.

In this essay, I am going to analyze the novel based on Part 3, Chapter 6 for my favorite extract in Atonement has been chosen as the example for our textbook. The extract tells how Briony goes to Cecilia’s, explains the whole crime she has committed and surprisingly notices that Robbie is still alive and living with her sister finally (in Briony’s imagination). This part is fall of dialogues and profile descriptions.

The first year in senior high school, I was luckily enough to have watched the renowned movie “Atonement”, which won an Oscar for Best Original Score, for the film stars James McAvoy and Keira Knightley in it were actually my favorite. The unusual narrative structure fascinated me, as the timeline was not continuous nor unified. The deep impression of the movie leads me to choose Atonement as my object of study.

The most intriguing aspect of the novel, that gives the title, is the error of perception made by Briony Tallis, which leads to a series of calamities consequently in the following years. From her vision of the world, she sees what she wants to see, and her interpretation of facts proves to be mistaken. The atonement to which the title refers becomes the goal of her life, and her text, as she struggles somehow to make amends for the irrevocable damage [3].

It is believed that figures of speech have the magical power of lighting up the language. There are words such as verbs, adjectives, nouns and even function words such as conjunctions, interjections and onomatopoeic words, etc.

What are mental words? Mental words can be named as internal words as well, for they refer to the representation of words such as nouns, adjectives and verbs relating to “psyche” and “mentality”, often act as marked voices, revealing writer’s peculation about a character’s feelings or thoughts [4]. Here are some examples I picked from the extract.

Briony remained in the shade of the portico and thought about the little present she would buy her friend- something delicious to eat, a banana, oranges, Swiss chocolate…, and she thought about food. (p237)

The mental words here are the underlined phrase and word- “thought about” which Ian McEwan used to suggest that Briony is having a complex inner world and complex psychological activities with erratic thoughts, and “delicious” showing that she’s having a happy memory. These are apparently a skill acknowledged to all applied broadly in stream of consciousness.

She became aware of the nervy, fidgeting music behind her the moment it ceased, and in the sudden new measure of silence, which seemed to confer freedom, she decided she must eat breakfast. (p237)

In the second case above, Brony’s memory is getting less relaxed and pleasant, for the music is nervy and fidgeting, just as the feelings she has got right now. her tension is getting even serious as she the meeting with Cecilia is becoming closer.

She turned her back and looked out at the quiet terraced houses in full sunlight, at the way she had come from the High Street. She was surprised to discover that she had no wish to leave yet, even though she was embarrassed by the long kiss, and dreaded what more there was to come. (p251)

The third case here happens after Cecilia pacifying Robbie who was pissed off arguing with Briony. Although “embarrassed” and “dreaded” are not positive adjectives, the embarrassed feelings are fairly described while the inner feeling of relief and joy seeing these two are still madly in love and can live together happily become more prominent with the contrast of the former ones.

Linguistic modality is also called mode. Using different modal verbs such as “might”, “would” and “could” as the classification of propositions according to whether they are contingently true or false, possible, impossible, or necessary. There are several examples listed below:

She decided she must eat breakfast. (p237)

She would not do so until invited, and she would never ask. (p246)

She should feel the need to withstand him. (p250)

Anything that might put his alibi in question. (p252).

If he couldn’t talk, he might have to act. (p250)

It is interesting that in this chapter of the whole novel, “would” is the most frequently used modal verb. The probability of different things decreases from “must”, “would”, “could” to “might”. And the “should” here means doing something unexpectedly.

Synaesthesia is a rhetorical device or figure of speech where one sense is described in terms of another. This may often take the form of a simile. One can distinguish the literary joining of terms derived from the vocabularies of sensory domains from synaesthesia as a neuropsychological phenomenon [5].

Then the creak of a stair, and feet wearing thick socks came into view. (P239)

In this case, what came into Briony’s view was not only visual sense, but also sound sensation of “the creak of a chair”. Outside the house, Briony was impossible to see what is going on inside the house, but she could make a guess by the clues given to her. With series of visual image followed, the synaesthesia makes the image more vividly and stereo, so that we can imagine just how her sister stood up from the chair drowsily and then stepped to the door.

Onomatopoeic words, in brief, is the imitation of natural sounds in word form. They can be the connection, or symbolism, of a sound that is interpreted and reproduced within the context of a language, usually out of mimicry of a sound. Generally speaking, no one can determine the meaning of a word purely by how it sounds. But in onomatopoeic words these sounds are much less arbitrary; they are connected in their imitation of other objects or sounds in nature [6].

Then the creak of a stair, and feet wearing thick socks came into view. (P239)

At last she heard the click of the lock on the bathroom door. (P246)

She showed her ticket and went through into the dirty yellow light, to the head of the clanking, creaking escalator. (p255)

In the cases above, McEwan used several onomatopoeic words to describe the sound of moving a chair, turning the key and the operating of escalators. Vocal sounds in the imitation of natural sounds doesn’t necessarily gain meaning, but can gain symbolic meaning. It creates the environment with us involved to use onomatopoeic words here, so that we can almost hear the sounds happening in the scene.

A numeral is a member of a word class characterized by the designation of numbers [7]. Numerals function most typically as an adjective or a pronoun and express numbers and relations to numbers for example: quantity, sequence, frequency, or fraction. I noticed that the author uses quite a few numerals in scenery description, and I chose an excerpt below:

The house was silent. Briony’ s view past the open front door was of a stretch of floral lino, and the first seven or eight stairs which were covered in deep red carpet.… The wallpaper was floral too—a posy of three roses alternating with a snowflake design. From the threshold to the beginning of the stairs she counted fifteen roses, sixteen snowflakes. Inauspicious. (p239)

This short paragraph portrays the scenery in front of the house. With these numerals used here, the descriptions are becoming detailed and realistic. They also indicate how nervous Briony was for she couldn’t help looking around the house and even counting out the exact numbers of those tiny little unimpressive things.

Fuzzy words also called hedgings or imprecise expressions, they are one of the meta- discourse signals in which the writer expresses uncertainty or qualification, which can be also a sign of flashback [8]. There are many sorts of fuzzy words, including adjectives of probability like “rarely”, “sometimes”, “likely” and “probably”, adjectives describing extent such as “almost”, “approximately”, “around” and “nearly”. Modal verbs such as “may”, “might” and “could” are also an important part of fuzzy words. It is interesting that “about” has been found to be the most used fuzzy word according to an investigation carried out by Lou Dubois, the English linguistician, among speeches of a medicine meeting [9]. The following sentences are examples using fuzzy words in Atonement.

The eyes were dark and enlarged, by fatigue perhaps. Or sorrow. (p240)

Cecilia had been about to take a bath. (p242)

On it was a jam jar of blue flowers, harebells perhaps, and a full ashtray, and a pile of books. (p243)

She hesitated, conscious that in answering she would be offering a form of defense, a rationale, and that it might enrage him further. (p249)

In these sentences, we find out that the author favors the word “perhaps” comparing to others. The first one is a description of Cecilia’s eyes. Briony is observing from the third person point of view. After so many years not seeing each other and so much misery she has suffered, Briony is not sure about her speculating. Maybe fatigue, maybe sad, or maybe both.

The second one is also a guess at Cecilia, which Briony made based on the humid atmosphere, and she is uncertain about her estimation, as well. The rest of examples are using fuzzy word out of almost the same reasons.

In English grammar, end-focus, also know as the Processibility Principle, is the principle which is a normally used characteristic of sentence structure in English, with the most important information in a clause or sentence is placed at the end purposely [10].

This structure is often used to focus the audience’s attention, make place for new information, change intonation or emphasize the information followed. These functions are exemplified as followed.

The eyes were dark and enlarged, by fatigue perhaps. Or sorrow. (p240)

Either you’re in, young lady, or you’re out. (p242)

She feared her sister, and her scorn. (p246)

But she was not frightened of him, not physically. (p248)

She felt obliterated, expunged from the room, and was relieved. (p250)

What she felt was more like homesickness, though there was no source for it, no home. (p255)

The first two are intended to express a new meaning. Cecilia’s eyes are dark and enlarged more likely due to sorrow, and the landlady wants Briony out more than in.

The third and fourth ones are emphasizing on and making further explanation of her fearing about her sister’s scorn and not physically frightened of Robbie. The penultimate one is a kind of climax, while the last one highlighted that she has no home anymore for the crime she committed.

Short sentences are usually used to be emphatic, and often the presentation of important facts and ideas. Writers also use them to be the force and clarify or vividly describe and make readers feel the extreme tension or characters’ feelings.

Slabs of ham, poached eggs, the leg of a roast chicken, thick Irish stew, lemon meringue. A cup of tea. (p237)

The eyes were dark and enlarged, by fatigue perhaps. Or sorrow. (p240)

Briony wanted to tell her how wonderful it was that Robbie had come back safely. What deliverance. (p246)

Short sentences are a writing feature of Ian McEwan. Seeing the first two, those short sentences are both emphatic, while the last one is a free indirect thought of Briony, aiming to readers feeling the same deliverance just as she does.

Parataxis is an arrangement of sentence, clauses, phrases, or words in coordinate rather than subordinate constructions, or words in connectives, or with coordinate conjunctions.[11] As in the following example, McEwan used this technique of parataxis with “and” being the connectives.

He wore army trousers and shirt and polished boots, and his braces hung free at his waist.

Using this kind of technique, readers like me can be able to make our own connections implied by the paratactic syntax. [12]

In rhetoric, an anaphora is a rhetorical device that consists of repeating a sequence of words at the beginnings of neighboring clauses, thereby lending them emphasis. The combination of anaphora and epistrophe results in symploce.

She would not do so until invited, and she would never ask.(p246)

She gave Briony a look, a cool glance to let her know that nothing had changed, nothing had softened. (p242)

In the second example, anaphora has the function of emphasizing Cecilia’s inner feelings, and also implies our readers’ emotions, so that we can be persuaded to the indifferent atmosphere between these two sisters. Other than the function of emphasizing ideas, the use of anaphora as a rhetorical device adds rhythm to the sentences, which making it more pleasurable to read and catchy, just as the former example here.

And the most used rhetorical device here is repletion, which is the simple repeating of a word, a phrase or a whole sentence, within a sentence or a poetical line, with no particular placement of the words, in order to secure emphasis. This is such a common literary device widely used as a figure of speech.

“Don’t call me that!” She repeated in a softer voice, “Please don’t call me that.” (p244)

“Don’t worry about that,” she said soothingly, and in the second or two during which she drew deeply on her cigarette, Briony flinched as her hopes lifted unreally. “Don’t worry,” her sister resumed. “I won’t ever forgive you.” (p244)

Nothing was, and there was nothing to talk about until Robbie came back. (p246)

These intermittent repetitions strengthening the tone and stressing the emotions of Cecilia, her hate, sorrow, anger and helplessness.

As is acknowledged to all that the dash is a punctuation mark. It has plenty of functions such as connecting symmetric items, in places of parentheses or a colon sometimes and setting off summaries or definitions. Vastly usage of dash marks is a feature throughout the fiction [13].

A decision had been made—without her, it seemed. (p237)

The wallpaper was floral too—a posy of three roses alternating with a snowflake design. (p239)

There was another obvious difference—Cecilia had always spoken to her in a motherly or condescending way. (p240)

He took a step toward her and she shrank back, no longer certain of his harmlessness—if he couldn’t talk, he might have to act. (p250)

The first and the last examples are used for supplementary instruction, and the

Further explanation

A rhetorical question is a figure of speech in the form of a question that is asked to make a point rather than to elicit an answer [14].

But who would believe that? (p244)

“Have you any idea at all what it’s like inside?” (p248)

“How much growing up do you need to do?” (p249)

These are either intended to start a discussion as is showed the last two, which also emphasizing the tone and the anger in Robbie’s mind, or draw an acknowledgement that readers understand the intended message in the first one that nobody would believe that.

Climax is a figure of speech in which words, phrases, or clauses are arranged in order of increasing importance [15]. Here are the examples.

It took all this time, all this movement, for Briony to realize that he was angry, very angry, and just as she did. (p247)

She had learned the little she knew, the tiny, next-to-nothing scraps that came the way of a trainee nurse, in the safety of the ward and the bedside.(p250)

With several things paralleling makes the final term seem still better or more important by comparison of the initial inferior options. Robbie is getting very angry instead of angry, and what Briony learnt was extremely tiny.

A flashback is an interjected scene that takes the narrative back in time from the current point in the story [16]. Here is a flashback of Briony when leaving her sister and Robbie. It’s warm, sweet, but will never happen again.

She used to speak like that to her sometimes, when Cecilia was sixteen and she was a child of six and things went impossibly wrong. Or in the night, when Cecilia came to rescue her from a nightmare and take her into her own bed. Those were the words she used. Come back. It was only a bad dream. Briony, come back. (p255)

The consecutive similes, metaphors and metonymies can be picturesque.

Since these rhetorical devices are fundamental, I’ll skip the definitions, only to illustrating a little.

Examples of Simile:

The walls were pape red with a design of pale vertical strips, like a boy’s pajamas. (p243)

This narrow room with its stripes like bars contained a history of feeling that no one could imagine. (p245)

As Cecilia gripped him tighter, he twisted his whole body away from her, and they seemed like wrestlers as she reached up and tried to turn his head toward her. (p250)

Here are examples of Metaphor:

The smooth wave rose. (p247)

The hardness in his gaze was new, and the eyes were smaller and narrower, and in the corners were the firm prints of crow’s feet.

Examples of Metonymy are listed below:

Briony recognized the tone. Pure Nightingale, for use on difficult patients or tearful students. (p242)

As a novel of postmodernism, it apparently shows qualities of postmodernism.

First of all, metafiction. The whole novel is a fiction written by Briony, the heroine in this fiction. The fiction explicitly and self- consciously reflects on the procedures of fiction.

Secondly, the stream of consciousness, which is a term describing how we experience consciousness as a fluid stream. With the novel full of interior monologues and free indirect discourse, this feature can be easily found.

Also, the shifting of point of view and tense, implies the instability of language. For example, part one, two and three are narrated from the third person POV with past tense. However, the last part is from the first person POV, with present tense. This technique is used through the reveal of the whole process and open ending.

The extract also applying pastiche, which refer to a work that contains a hodgepodge of elements or fragments from different source or influences.

McEwan favors montage as well, the distinctive feature both in the novel and the movie, which does not conform to the authenticity arrangement of events. Repetive montage, psychological montage and parallel montage are the most used kinds.

The creating principles of Intertextuality, the status of all texts as composites or amalgams of other texts, are also basic characteristics of postmodern novels. No text is isolated from others. Some of the plots adapted from Twelfth Night, and roles in Atonement, can also be traced to the source of several novels, including Northanger Abbey by Jane Austin, Mrs. Dalloway by Virginia Woolf [17].

For Atonement, indeterminacy embodied both in the uncertainty of characteristic and plot. For one thing, Danny Herdman and Jack are two unclear while important characters in the novel. For the other, there are numerous uncertainties in the plots, such as the reason that Briony stands out to indict Robbie for, whether she saw the rapist clearly, etc.

In conclusion, this novel is definitely a masterpiece of modernism.

[1] https://www.salon.com/2012/11/14/ian_mcewan_novelist_historian/

[2] Pedot R. Rewriting(s) in Ian McEwan's 'Atonement'[J]. Etudes Anglaises, 2007, 60(2):148-159.

[3] 索玉柱,小说风格笔记[6], 9

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synaesthesia_(rhetorical_device)

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onomatopoeia#Onomatopoeia_in_linguistics

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Numeral_(linguistics)

[7] 索玉柱,英文小说风格鉴赏,2017, 141.

[8] 张荣建. 英语模糊词浅谈[J]. 语言教育, 1989(6):32-33.

[9] https://www.thoughtco.com/end-focus-sentence-structure-1690593

[10] 索玉柱,英文小说风格鉴赏,2017, 69.

[11] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parataxis

[12] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dash#Usage_2

[13] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhetorical_question

[14] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climax_(rhetoric)

[15] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flashback_(narrative)

[16] 李涯. 罪无可赎的后现代文本——论麦克尤恩《赎罪》的解构叙事[J]. 当代文坛, 2012(1):102-104.

[17] 王秀. 《赎罪》中的后现代现实主义分析[D]. 辽宁大学, 2014.

[18] David K. O'Hara. Briony's Being-For: Metafictional Narrative Ethics in Ian McEwan's Atonement[J]. Critique Studies in Contemporary Fiction, 2011, 52(1):74-100.

本文由作者上传并发布(或网友转载),绿林网仅提供信息发布平台。文章仅代表作者个人观点,未经作者许可,不可转载。
点击查看全文
相关推荐
热门推荐