《PERL HACKS》读后感摘抄

《PERL HACKS》是一本由Chromatic著作，清华大学出版社出版的平装图书，本书定价：38.0，页数：290，特精心收集的读后感，希望对大家能有帮助。

《PERL HACKS》读后感(一)：内容很好，翻译质量一般

Perl Hacks绝对是Perl界的经典之作，100个实用技巧哪怕只用到十分之一也能使你的工作事半功倍。

不过翻译质量就差强人意了，好在基本上能将意思表达清楚，不至于误解，就可以了。

《PERL HACKS》读后感(二)：珍爱生命，远离清华

看到又是清华大学出版社，我就很确定的将这本书的中译版列入黑名单了。现在的清华大学出版社早就不是4、5年前那个了。手边除了一本linux server hacks之外，就没有清华出的中译版的书了，但这并不影响我做出这个结论。chinapub上无数的读者用自己的金钱和时间验证着我的论断：

if (press==清华大学出版社)

{

if(中文版)

dropit;

else

if(havenoINDEX)

dropit;

}

《PERL HACKS》读后感(三)：烂翻译！诅咒译者！

from Barret

to info@mail.oreilly.com.cn

cc bookquestions@oreilly.com

date Fri, Mar 9, 2007 at 5:01 PM

subject 对简体版本 Perl Hacks 严重失望！

Dear Sirs/Madams，

I hereby express my extreme angry complaint and disappointment on one

book I bought -- O'reilly Perl Hacks Simplified Chinese Translation by

Liu Ying of Tsinghua University Express.

O'reilly is a qualified computer punisher popular in China IT field,

although the books are usually a little expensive. However, Perl Hacks

SimCHN Translation is full of mistakes.

Here are some examples:

1：the translator knows nothing about IT jargons:

P44 Hack#13："又只有在其首次阅读期间神奇般的自开放"。

but only magically self-opens during the first read operation on it ，

The "read" has been translated into chinese as "read" in "reading

book". Differ from "read" as in "read a file".

2：the translator knows nothing about English life:

P53 Hack#16 的"除非你是卡片游戏机排外的狂热爱好者"。

Unless you're exclusively a fan of card games，

"card game"has been wrongly translated into "card game console" while

"CPU power"，has been translated into "CPU is more powerful" in

Chinese.

3：the translator knows nothing about English:

P62 Hack#18："Mozilla Firefox 的 Greasemonkey 扩展程序和相关的浏览器"。

The Greasemonkey extension for Mozilla Firefox and related browsers。

The book writes "The Greasemonkey extension for Mozilla Firefox, and

the related browsers". The same mistake happend at:

P72 Hack#21 "在电子表格中显示所有数据"

Showing all data in a spreadsheet。

Being wrongly translated into: Showing all the data in your spreadsheet.

The translator amazes to me.

4：the translator knows nothing about using a (fine) dictionary:

P185 Hack#66："窃取基准"。

原文：Cheat on Benchmarks。

The translator decides "Stealing the benchmarks".

I don't know where can he or she go any further.

I'd like to hear from you about my complaints. Or "no news is good news？"

Regards.